The various developmental initiatives by the government have fallen short of achieving their intended objectives. Is it a design issue or an implementation bottleneck? Suggest measures to improve the effectiveness of developmental schemes.
Devyanshi Kaura, AIR 71, 2025
Multiple developmental schemes are in place to tackle poverty, undernutrition and illiteracy. Yet, gulf between actual and intended targets persists.
Design issues in Government policies 1. Absence of mechanisms for feedback from intended beneficiaries and citizen groups 2. Conflicting objectives across schemes formulated in silos by different ministries 3. Lack of clear SOPs to hold officials accountable for performance 4. Poorly formulated laws without empirical analysis 5. Scheme multiplicity - resources spread thinly and lack of synergies - eg between public works programs and jobs guarantee
Implementation issues 1. Status quoism of bureaucracy - attitude issues, poor innovation, file and armchair culture 2. Devolution to lower levels of government is poor - as seen in Ministry of Panchayati Raj Index of devolution 3. Perpetual problem of low fund allocation. eg - overall health and education spend is below 5% of GDP 4. Leakages and corruption 5. Low awareness and capacity building 6. ICT potential not fully exploited to increase efficiency in service delivery 7. Issues of departmental coordination and turf wars 8. Cronyism and capture of policy by vested groups - eg hijack of land reform agenda by large owners
Institutional reform through political prioritisation, bureaucratic efficiency and citizen participation is key to make state's developmental role effective.