Topper Copies

What do you understand by Alternate Dispute Redressal (ADR) mechanisms? What are the reasons for their low adoption as the primary mode of dispute resolution in the country? Suggest measures for improvement.

Devyanshi Kaura, AIR 71, 2025

Alternate Dispute Resolution refers to a set of mechanisms by which disputes are resolved outside the traditional court system, as a means of providing quick and inexpensive justice, as well as reducing the burden on the traditional court system.

Mechanisms under ADR include : 1. Arbitration - arbitrator decides dispute on principles of natural justice 2. Conciliation - neutral conciliator allows both parties to resolve together 3. Negotiation - both parties amicably resolve dispute among themselves 4. Mediation - Neutral third party who acts as conduit to allow both parties to come to a settlement

- ADR is permitted only for compoundable offences of petty nature, or civil disputes

Reasons for low adoption of ADR in India 1. ADR awards can be taken back to traditional courts - through fresh cases or as challenges - this makes them just another dilatory step 2. Difficult to enforce ADR award if one party unilaterally violates 3. ADR itself time consuming: - significant delays in proceedings - incentive for mediators, conciliators to delay 4. Lack of professionalised HR for ADR: - currently undertaken by persons with Judicial experience, unable to bring alternate skillset to ADR which it requires 5. Poor contract enforcement in India - - has eroded legitimacy and trust of parties in the system

Measures for improvement of ADR : 1. Enhancing fund allocation for Arbitration and conciliation councils - - for better human resource training and management - creating adequate and dedicated cadre for ADR 2. Setting technical standards for arbitrators and conciliators : - Similar to how insolvency professionals are certified 3. Better contract enforcement norms - reducing discretionary powers of public servants - use of digital solutions to detect deviations, lodge complaints

Rejuvenation of ADR can go a long way in improving dispute resolution and allow courts to refocus on their role as defenders of rights.