Topper Copies

What circumstances led to the formation of the National Green Tribunal? Evaluate if it has met its stated objectives in more than a decade of its existence.

Devyanshi Kaura, AIR 71, 2025

National Green Tribunal was set up in 2010 through the NGT Act with the purpose of being a specialised court for environmental and sustainability issues.

Circumstances leading to formation of NGT. 1. 1990s - Justice PN Bhagwati suggests setting up of special courts for environmental matters. 2. MC. Mehta case, 1998: - SC emphasis right to healthy environment as part of Article 21 - Increasing tension between development and environment requires evolution of separate jurisprudence 3. 2000s - SC evolves principles to govern environmental jurisprudence including - Polluter Pays; Precautionary principle 4. 2010 - NGT setup with principal bench at New Delhi and additional benches in Bhopal, Chennai, Kolkata - required to dispose of cases within 6 months - composed of minimum 10 members including Judicial and expert members, Maximum 20

Evaluation of NGT - success in meeting objective 1. Consideration of environmental repurcussions of mega industrial projects eg - recent case of Great Nicobar transshipment container port project 2. Evolution of principles and their application. eg - Polluter pays - in Srinagar Bandh Aapda Sangarsh Samiti case, 2013 3. Directing environmental action by authorities - areas like solid waste management, species conservation

Shortcomings in NGT's performance 1. Vacancies in NGT: - Requirement of 10 minimum members, yet instances of NGT operating with less than that 2. Rising cases and pendency due to understaffing 3. Stalling of key development projects due to NGT are considered to have negative impact on growth. Concerns about lack of balance in NGT's approach 4. NGT cannot hear cases under wildlife Protection Act, 1974 - limits its role and effectiveness 5. Judicial displacement - decision making handed to expert committees effectively displacing judicial powers to executive functionaries

NGT has on the average been effective at its protective role towards environment. Proper human resource management is required to increase its efficiency.