An archaic and obsolete edifice of civil services does not augur well for a welfare state. Examine the various issues surrounding the civil services in the country. What suggestions would you make for their reform?
Devyanshi Kaura, AIR 71, 2025
Former PM Jawaharlal Nehru considered it to be a major failure - the failure to reform the civil service from a colonial institution to one suited for development.
Various issues plaguing Civil Service 1. Recruitment issues - need to reform process - psychosocial profile of candidates missing - systemic manipulation of safeguards eg - recent Pooja Khedkar PwD reservation scam 2. Skill and domain expertise missing - generalists recruited - low midcareer training & specialisation 3. Size of bureaucracy - overall size is too low - popn to civil service ratio lower than USA - However composition is skewed - - overstaffing at higher levels - understaffed at street level 4. Attitudinal issues: - status quoist, rule based and hierarchical => delays and inefficiency in work - power concentration - armchair planners 5. Competitiveness low: - only hire, no fire - low lateral entry 6. Corruption - public office misuse, public funds siphoned
Suggestions to Reform Civil Service - as suggested by ARC1 and ARC2 - Recruitment reforms - better screening processes - establishing psychosocial profile - Training reforms - Suitable midcareer training at fixed intervals - promotion linked to successful completion and performance. Eg - Mission Karmayogi - Performance Appraisal - yearly targets quantified with a definite scoring system - Performance linked incentives - Accountability - Accountability from below - social audit, citizen charter, time bound service delivery laws - from above - CVC, CAG, CBI, ED - must be allowed autonomous functioning
Civil service reform is essential to realize peoples aspirations - to create a 'Trusted Steel frame' instead of a 'Rusted Steel frame'.