"What was hailed as sunshine legislation, has been overshadowed by dark clouds". Critically examine the statement in the context of implementation of Right to information Act in almost two decades, since its enactment.
Devyanshi Kaura, AIR 71, 2025
ARC2 deemed RTI as the 'Masterkey of Good governance', calling it a guarantee against corruption and impropriety.
Positive contribution of RTI Act 1. Helped in realisation of entitlements and dues 2. Set trend for other rights based legislations. eg - Right to work (MGNREGA), Right to food (Food security Act 2013) 3. Exposing government scams and corruption at local level
However, onetime RTI has lost steam.
Issues in implementation of RTI 1. Inadequate funding -> weak suo moto disclosures, no training of PIOs, filing isn't easy. Only 40% of ICs have e-filing facility 2. Rank juniors appointed as PIOs without additional incentives 3. Information commissions dominated by retired bureaucrats - poor outlook -> over 95% cases, no penalty imposed 4. Pendency problem due to staffing issues - over 3 Lac complaints pending 5. New changes to RTI Act, 2019 - have reduced independence of ICs 6. Poor record management despite 20 years of RTI - hinders easy access 7. Abuse of schedule 2 to shield abuses by security forces
RTI is now in need of second Push. Measures like increased funding, record digitisation and bureaucratic training and restructuring are required.