The political reorganisation of states and territories has been ongoing process in post independence era. Discuss with examples. How successful has it been in accomodating diverse Regional aspirations?
Aditya Acharya, AIR 96, 2024
Though India attained political freedom from British in 1947 but internal readjustment of boundaries of states continues till date due to varied demands.
Reorganisation of states: Continuing process
1. JVP Committee - rejected linguistic state of Andhra Pradesh - Potti Srimalulu died - violent riots. - Andhra Pradesh created. 2. states Reorganisation Commission (KM Pannikar, HN Kunzru, Fazal Ali) - Laid down parameters for linguistic reorganisation and other metrics. 3. Gujarat created out of maharashtra on basis of language. 4. PEPSU - organised into one state. 5. Rajputana states merged to form Rajasthan 6. Nagaland, Arunachal carved out of Assam 7. Sikkim integrated into Indian Union.
In contemporary times reorganisation continues:
1. separation of Jharkhand and Chattisgarh from Bihar, MP 2. Uttrakhand carved out of UP. 3. Telangana & Andhra Pradesh separated 4. J&K separated from Ladakh and made UT
There are impending demands for Bodoland, Harit Pradesh, Vidharbha etc.
Accomodating regional aspirations
| Helped | Not helped | | --- | --- | | 1. Acted as safety valve avoided violent regional movements. (Eg) Uttrakhand. | 1. Domino effect - more such never ending demands. (Eg) Bodoland, Vidharbha | | 2. Addressed genuine demands of locals (E) Telangana | 2. developmental deficit + Precarious economic situation -> Jharkhand + Chattisgarh | | 3. Made governance closer to citizens -> smaller states -> better admin. | 3. federal issues exacerbated over share of resources (E) Dispute between Punjab & Haryana over SYL. | | 4. strengthened unity and integrity of India (E) linguistic reorganisation | |
Therefore states reorganisation has been a mixed bag and must be assess on case to case basis.