Topper Copies

Do you think UCC is essential in a multi-cultural & diverse country like India. Justify your answer.

Aditya Acharya, AIR 96, 2024

UCC under Article 44 of Indian constitution refers to common set of laws governing personal matters like marriage inheritance etc of all religious community

Need of UCC

1. curb rising social / religious polarisation -> Goa common civil code. 2. Gender Equality - eliminate rules that are against gender equality & constitutional morality - (E) Triple talaq. 3. Forge common national identity over religious identity 4. Ensure secularism in practice in real terms 5. streamlining laws for legal efficiency

Therefore UCC can strengthen multiculturalism in diverse country like India.

Arguments against UCC

1. Fear of majoritarianism: accomodating majority religion practices & discarding minority religion practices in UCC. 2. Goes against Article 29 & 30 which safeguards minority cultural & religious autonomy 3. Lack of political will and challenge from religious orthodoxy

way forward

Rather than pushing down / imposing UCC from above, efforts must be made for general consensus over UCC with stakeholder consultation (Law commission)

Till then, gradual change and internal reforms like Triple Talaq must be carried out.