State Arrow's five reasonable conditions which a social welfare function must satisfy.
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
Arrow made an attempt to derive social choice based on individual preferences through democratic voting process. He laid down five conditions for the welfare function to satisfy to truely reflect the individual preferences.
Arrow's 5 reasonable conditions.
1. Non-dictatorship - Preferences of all individuals should be considered with everyone having their choice without any imposition. 2. Independence of irrelevant alternatives - Any change in irrelevant alternatives should not affect the final preference - Eg: If A > B > C, then if C is removed, then still A should be preferred over B. 3. Unrestricted Domain. - Preferences of every individual should be considered & no one should be left out. 4. Pareto Efficiency - Unanimous preference should be respected. - If every voter prefer A over B, candidate A should win. 5. Social Ordering - Ordering must be consistent & transitive.
Based on these conditions, Arrow stated the Impossibility theorem which is a social choice paradox as it states the impossibility to make social choices without violating any one of the above 5 conditions.
Lets say there are 3 alternatives (x,y,z) & 3 individuals (A,B,C)
The figure highlights the preferences of 3 individuals, with 1 being the highest preferences.
| | X | Y | Z | |---|---|---|---| | A | 1 | 2 | 3 | | B | 2 | 3 | 1 | | C | 3 | 1 | 2 |
Here, A & B prefer x over y B & C prefer z over x A & C prefer y over z
Thus, inconsistent results.
∴ Arrow explained the impossibility in democratic process to make social choices.
This was criticized by Amartya Sen as this limitation was arisen due to shortage of information in the model.