Is stagflation a logical outcome of Keynesian orthodoxy? Give reasons for your answer.
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
Stagflation is a situation of high inflation and high level of unemployment in the economy. The 1970s oil crisis resulted in stagflation in various global economies & challenged the existing macro-economic theories.
The Keynesian Orthodoxy propounded a tradeoff between inflation and unemployment and this was challenged by Stagflation as this trade-off was broken.
Stagflation was not a logical outcome of Keynesian Orthodoxy as:
1. Keynesian economics focussed on aggregate demand in explaining output and employment - But, stagflation was caused by supply side shocks which was not considered in Keynesian Orthodoxy. 2. Policy implications. - With stagflation & supply shocks, AS curve shifts left.
[graph: price level against quantity, AD and AD' with AS and AS', arrows showing AS shifting up-left and AD shifting up-right, prices P1, P2 and quantities Q1, Q] - Keynesians proposed increase in fiscal spending to tackle the situation - This worsened the situation as it further increased inflation. 3. Keynesians assumed prices to be constant due to excess capacity in the economy. - But during stagflation, prices increased despite unutilized capacity in the economy. 4. Keynesian Orthodoxy could not explain the failing of Philips curve with inflation & unemployment rising simultaneously. 5. With assumptions of Keynesian model breaking like closed economy, price constancy and horizontal supply curve due to excess capacity, it failed to explain Stagflation.
∴ Stagflation is not a logical outcome of Keynesian Orthodoxy. This forced for a change in macro-economic theories and paved way for Neo-classical & Neo-Keynesian theories.