Distinguish between monopolistic and monopsonistic exploitations in determining wage rate under imperfect competition.
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
In the presence of perfect competition, wage rate is determined by Marginal Revenue Product (MRP) which equals Value of Marginal Product (VMP) W = MRP = VMP But this condition fails down in the case of imperfect markets in product & labour markets.
Monopolistic Exploitation
- This situation arises when there is monopoly in the labour product market & perfect competition in labour market. - With perfect competition in labour market, firm has no control over wage rate & the supply of labour.
[two graphs: "Industry" with wage rate against employment; "Firm" with VMP (point H), MRP (point E) and a horizontal MFC line, wage levels W and employment N1, N2] Fig: Monopolistic exploitation.
The equilibrium is established where, W = MRP, & this is lower than VMP due to monopoly in product market. - The difference between MRP & VMP (EH) highlights the Monopolistic exploitation in determining wage rate. - Results in lower employment in a firm.
Monopsonistic exploitation.
This arises due to Monopsony in labour market and monopoly in Product market. - with only a single buyer in labour
With monopoly in product market, equilibrium is established where MRP = MFC .
[graph: wage rate against employment with MFC, AFC, VMP and MRP lines, wage levels W, W1, W2 and points H, E, G]
But the labour is not paid wage W, , as monopsony is present in labour market. - The single buyer pays wage rate equal to Average factor cost & thus wage rate of W is established.
∴ E on H highlights the monopolistic exploitation & E on G highlights monopsonistic exploitation in determining wage rates.
This market will differ if the labours organize themselves into unions, as it leads to a Bilateral monopoly case.