Compare the Kaldor-hicks criterion with the pareto criterion in assessing changes in welfare due to a new policy.
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
Pareto criterion states that, if any economic reorganization of resources will increase will welfare if it makes someone better off without making any one worse-off.
Let say, initial endowment results in point P as Utility possibility space. As per the pareto criterion, any reorganization of resources which moves results in shift to any point between R & S would increase welfare & is pareto optimal.
[graph: Utility of B against Utility of A, a concave frontier with R and S on the curve and P inside it]
- As it increases utility of one individual without decreasing other's utility.
The major drawback of this criterion is that, it cannot assess any policy which makes few better off & others worse-off.
Kaldor & Hicks criterion solves this problem by stating that, any reorganization or policy change is improvement in welfare if the gainers are able to compensate the losers & still be better off. - This is Kaldor Hicks compensation principle.
Lets say, the initial utility distribution at point P & with a policy change, it shifts to point Q. With means redistribution, the gainers can compensate the losers and reach any point between R & S and thus this increases their welfare.
[graph: B's Utility against A's Utility, a concave frontier with Q, R and S, and P inside it]
A major drawback was identified by Scitovsky, where there is an intersection between the utility possibility frontiers.
As per Kaldor-Hicks criterion, D is improvement over C as we can move to point F from D with redistribution. Similarly, C is improvement over D as we can move from C to E. Thus contradictory results.
[graph: B's Utility against A's Utility, two intersecting downward-sloping frontiers with points F, C, E and D]
∴ For any increase in welfare 2, tests were proposed by Scitovsky - Kaldor-Hicks tests - Reversal test - States that the gainers should be able to persuade the losers for policy change and losers cannot persuade the gainers for the change.
Both models followed few restrictive assumptions such as Perfect competition, Ordinal utility analysis, Classical assumption & seperation of problem of distribution from problem of exchange & production.
Economists such as Little & Amartya Sen criticized these models for its indeterminacy and its basis on utility analysis.