State Marshallian and Walrsian stability condition of market equilibrium. Do you think that existence of Marshallian stability necessarily ensures Walrasian stability and vice versa? Explain.
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
Marshallian equilibrium is based on quantity adjustment and partial equilibrium analysis. Stability is reached when the slope of demand curve is greater than supply curve.
At any quantity to the left of Q, Demand price should be greater than supply price for stability.
[supply-demand graph: P1, P, P2 on the price axis, Q' and Q on the quantity axis]
If P_d > P_s, quantity will increase & vice versa.
Walrasian equilibrium is based on price adjustment or tatonnement process & is a general equilibrium analysis. Stability is reached when excess demand function has a negative slope.
For any point below P, Quantity demanded should be greater than quantity supplied.
[supply-demand graph: P and P1 on the price axis, Q1, Q and Q2 on the quantity axis]
If E_d>0, prices will increase & vice versa.
Existence of Marshallian stability does not ensure Walrasian stability & vice-versa.
[two supply-demand graphs: Fig 1 Marshallian Stable, with D steeper than S; Fig 2 : Walrasian stable, with S steeper than D]
Figure 1 is Marshallian stable and Unstable as per Walras as below price P, Excess demand is negative. => Fall in price Figure 2 is Marshallian Unstable as to the left of Q, P_s > P_d => Quantity will fall.