Compare and contrast tariffs, quotas and subsidies as instrument of trade protection.
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
Tariffs, quotas & subsidies are different tools of trade protection used by nations to restrict trade to achieve its domestic objectives. Comparison between tariffs, quotas & subsidies
1. Tariffs are a tax levied on export or import of a commodity => ex: US tariffs on China - Quotas are restriction placed on exports or imports to control trade to a fixed quantity - ex: Export quotas over cereals by India. - Subsidies are payments made to exporters to incentivize the growth of trade. - can also be applied on other aspects of economy. 2. Tariffs increase the domestic price of imports thereby reducing imports. - Quota restrict import to fixed quantity & subsidies are usually to protect domestic industry to compete in global markets. 3. Tariffs on imports and export subsidies increase domestic prices but decrease global prices as import tariffs improve terms of trade, and subsidies increase global supply. - Quotas have ambiguous effect on terms of trade but increase domestic prices. 4. Any change in demand and supply conditions affect the quantity under tariffs and subsidies. But it only effects prices under quotas. 5. Further, tariffs increases government revenue, whereas subsidies results in loss.
All forms will suffer from dead weight loss.