Explain how the crowding out effect differs under classical and Keynesian assumptions. What role do wage-price rigidities play in shaping these outcomes?
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
Crowding out effect is a phenomenon of fall in private investment due to rise in interest rates caused by increase in government spending. Increased government spending reduces supply of funds and increases the interest rates.
Crowding out effect under Classical Assumptions
Assumptions under classical model: - Wage-price flexibility - Full employment equilibrium - Perfect competition and information. - Closed economy and capital and technology are constant. - Interest rate stabilizes S & I.
Under these assumptions, the LM curve remains vertical due to interest rate inelasticity of money demand. Under Classical model, interest rates play a stabilizing role between s&I and money variables do not impact the interest rates. ∴ M(d) = f(Y) Due to these assumptions, any change in fiscal policy would only impact price as per the IS-LM model.
If classical model is considered, increase in G would lead to change in interest rates and thus will have no impact on AD as a whole. If these assumptions are applied to Neo-classical model, LM curve becomes vertical, and any changes in fiscal policy will cause full crowding out as it increases the interest rates which result in a fall in Investment.
[an IS-LM graph with a vertical LM line and IS shifting outward, interest rates r1 and r2]
Crowding out under Keynesian Assumption
Keynesian model assumed high interest rate elasticity of money demand in situations of liquidity trap which resulted in a horizontal LM curve.
Other assumptions: - Price is constant - G, I are exogenous - Wage rigidity.
With increase in government spending, the interest rates do not rise as Money demand is highly elastic to interest rates. As a result there is no crowding effect under pure Keynesian assumptions.
[an IS-LM graph with a horizontal LM line and IS shifting to IS', income Y1 to Y2]
Wage-Price rigidities play a major role in shaping the outcomes of Classical model and Keynesian model.
Perfect wage-price flexibility in Classical model results in a vertical supply curve which prevents any rise in Income with changes in aggregate demand. Thus wage-price flexibility makes monetary policy also as ineffective under Classical assumptions.
Whereas in Keynesian model, wage rigidity based on money illusion results in upward sloping aggregate supply curve which reduces crowding out. Further Keynes assumed price to be constant as due to huge unutilized capacity in the economy during depression which further makes AS curve horizontal resulting in zero crowding out.