Topper Copies

Does a monopolistically competitive market lead to excess capacity under price competition?

S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025

Excess capacity is the difference between a firm's output level and the socially optimum level determined by output under perfect competition.

In monopolistically competitive market, firm faces a downward sloping demand curve and determines its output level by equating marginal revenue & marginal cost.

In long run, a firm under monopolistic competition reaches equilibrium at Price P₁ & produces Q₁. The equilibrium is reached on falling portion of long run cost curve (LAC)

[a graph of price against quantity with D, MR, a U-shaped LAC and MC, price P1 and quantities Q1 and Q2; Fig: LR eq. under monopolistic competition]

Thus output level Q, is lower than Perfectly competitive firm output Q2, determined at lowest point of LAC curve. And this difference Q,Q2 highlights excess capacity of the firm.

This is caused by downward sloping demand curve and free entry of new firms which causes business stealing and shifts demand curve for each firm to the left leaving excess capacity in each firm.

But according to Chamberlin, a true monopolistically competitive firm does not cause any excess capacity if there is free entry and exit. The shortage in output produced is due to greater product differentiation and choice for consumers. The product differentiation justifies this shortage according to Chamberlin and does not cause any allocative inefficiency. He determined that excess capacity only exists if there is non-price competition in the economy.

The real world economies suggest high non-price competition between oligopolistic firms as observed in consumer goods and this signals excess capacity in the economy.

[a graph with a downward-sloping demand line and a curve tangent to a U-shaped average cost curve, with dashed verticals to the quantity axis]