“Balanced budget is not fiscal neutral”. Comment.
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
Balanced budget is a situation when the entire government expenditure is financed by government revenues resulting in a balance in budget finances.
Balanced budget is not fiscal neutral as ₹1 increase in government expenditure which is financed by ₹1 increase in government taxes would increase the GDP by ₹1. This is illustrated below.
At equilibrium, Y = Aggregate Demand. Y = C + I + G [assume closed economy] Let C = a + bY_D where Y_D = Y - T and b is marginal propensity to consume. Y = a + b(Y - T) + I + G I & G are considered to be exogenous.
Y = a + bY - bT + I + Gr
Y = 1/(1-b) (a - bT + I + Gr)
government expenditure multiplier:
ΔY/ΔGr = 1/(1-b)
Taxation multiplier:
ΔY/ΔT = -b/(1-b)
∴ ΔY/ΔGr + ΔY/ΔT = 1/(1-b) - b/(1-b) = 1
Thus, balanced budget is not fiscal neutral as government expenditure increases GDP by a greater amount in the economy.