Critically assess the Drain Theory and its relevance in explaining the economic underdevelopment of colonial India.
Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025
Drain Theory was propounded by Dadabhai Naoroji in his 'Poverty and Un-British India'. It says British rule led to withdrawal of wealth from India to Britain which was cause of miseries in India. Thus drain was that proportion of national product which was not available for domestic consumption. According to Dadabhai, it was 200-300 million pound while as per Habib's estimate, it was 2% of national income.
Relevance in explaining underdevelopment
Agriculture
- Investment :- drain in the form of higher land revenue led to lack of surplus left for investment in land -> productivity fell - As drain of wealth led to de-industrialization it increased pressure on land, as share of workforce in agriculture increased. - Data :- 55% -> 70% (1860 to 1911)
Industry
- Drain led to low purchasing power and thus reduced demand for handicrafts -> one reason for de-industrialization - Drain of wealth prevented infrastructure development in India -> India somewhat missed industrialization stage.
Welfare
- Reduced purchasing power of people -> increased poverty - Famines :- drain caused frequent famines as productivity of agriculture fell. - Drain of wealth constrained government's ability to spend on education, health, etc. → social welfare did not occur.
Counterview
According to economists like Tirthankar Roy, drain theory lays down exaggerated claims as a good proportion of the so called 'drain' was re-invested in the country to establish railway network, postal services, telegraph lines, irrigation canals, among others.