What are the components of Land Reforms in India? Has it been completed? If not, then what are the obstacles?
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
Land reforms was a major priority after independence & the Kumarappa committee clearly listed the components of land reforms.
Components of land reforms
1. Abolition of Intermediaries or Zamindars. 2. Tenancy reforms - (i) Regulation of rent - (ii) Provision of ownership rights to tenants. - (iii) Security of tenure to tenants 3. Ceiling on landholdings => to ensure equitable distribution & prevent concentration of ownership 4. Consolidation of landholdings 5. Cooperative farmings 6. Measures to augment farmer welfare.
Performance of these reforms was aptly mentioned by P.S. Appu in 1992 - Out of 3 programmes, abolition of intermediaries was implemented fairly well but other reforms failed due to gaps between policy legislation & policy implementation.
[Empirical evidence of these reforms]
(i) Abolition of intermediaries ⇒ 1.7 crore tenants were brought into direct relation with State as per K.N. Raj report. - Highlights success of abolition of intermediaries.
(ii) Poor performance of other reforms
- Tenancy reforms - High rents fixed in States like Bihar & exclusion of sharecroppers from definition of tenants in states like Bengal. - Land ceilings : As per 12th plan document, hardly 2% of sown area (72 lakh acres) was declared as surplus - Consolidation of land holdings was only done 1/3rd of total consolidable area - Tajamul Haque - Poor implementation of cooperative reforms was highlighted in Nijalingappa committee
Thus as a result, the land reforms were not completed as mentioned in chart given by Swaminathan report.
[a bar chart of % of total land owned, Top 10% about 54% against Bottom 50% 3%; Fig: Land Ownership Inequality in 1991]
Reasons / Obstacles for these reforms
1. Snags in legislation : Personal cultivation Clause, high limits & exemptions resulted in poor implementation. 2. Lack of Political will : Tajamul Haque mentioned that by 1980s, political interest shifted to marketing policies. 3. Bureaucratic apathy : Frequent transfers of honest officers & upper bureaucrats being landowners => Hari charan Singh Committee report. 4. Uneven implementation across states 5. Imbalance in usual power => resulted in voluntary surrenders & oral lease agreements 6. Lack of digital & formal land records
Thus, there is need for land reforms as FAO has highlighted that 5% of redistribution of land would reduce usual Poverty by 20%.