Do you think that the ‘new guarantee’ system was better than the ‘old guarantee’ system in the history of Railways in India? Give reasons.
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
The British government developed railways under the guarantee system which provided guaranteed returns to the private companies if they incure any operational losses.
New Guarantee System (NGs) better than Old Guarantee system (OGs)
1. The guaranteed returns were reduced from 5% in OGs to 3.5% in NGs. 2. The share in surplus profits was increased to 3/5th to government from 1/2 in OGs. 3. The railways were declared as the State Property from the beginning & right to terminate contracts after 25 years - This was unlike OGs, where government had a right to buy back after 25 years. 4. Average speed of construction - Higher under NGs with 750 miles per year whereas 450 miles under OGs.
But still NGs had its challenges.
As aptly stated by Irfan Habib, railways were built using British capital but returns were guaranteed from Indian revenues resulting in huge flow of wealth from India to British