Distinguish between pure public goods, private goods and mixed goods. In which way can one achieve Pareto optimality when an economy provides private and public goods? Discuss.
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
The concept of public goods was given by A. Samuelson in his work "The Pure theory of public expenditure" & they are differentiated with private and mixed goods based the excludability & rival nature of goods.
Difference between Pure Public, private & mixed goods.
1. Pure public goods are characterized by non excludability & non-rival in nature. - Non-excludability: An individual cannot be excluded for a provision of public good. - Non-rival: Consumption of good by one individual does not affect the consumption for another individuals.
| | Rival | Non-Rival | |----------------|-------|-----------| | Excludable | A | B | | Non Excludable | C | D |
-> The product D is a pure public good. -> Whereas A is private good & B & C are public goods.
2. Public goods include goods such as defense, street lighting, etc. - Private goods => laptops, restaurants. - Mixed goods (B) => Toll booths. - Mixed goods (C) => Parks => lead to congestion after a limit. 3. Public goods result in market failure due to externalities and free riders problem & require government intervention - Private goods are effectively provided by market - Mixed goods require a combination of both based on conditions.
Pareto optimality for Private & Public goods.
1) Private goods
-> for private goods, pareto optimality is achieved when no one is able to being made better off without making some one worse off & this occurs when the pareto optimal conditions are satisfied
MRS^A_XY = MRS^B_XY = MRT_XY
-> Marginal rate of substitution between 2 goods equal marginal rate of transformation -> This can be achieved by ensuring Perfect markets and absence of externalities -> In presence of externalities government can intervene to correct the market through taxes or subsidies.
2) Public goods
-> For public goods, Pareto optimality is reached when marginal benefit by all individuals equals the payment made by them & the net summation equals the Marginal cost of producing the good.
-> This is achieved if each individual Pays exactly as per their Marginal benefit recieved.
-> This can be achieved through 1. Lindahl pricing as per benefits recieved principle 2. Government taxation to ensure true reflection of prices.
But reaching Pareto optimality in case of public goods become difficult as individuals do not truely reveal their marginal benefit recieved from a pure public good.