What is the difference between Fisher's theory and Cambridge cash balance approach to quantity theory of money? What is the criticism of each? Which one is more relevant in present context? Justify.
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
Irving Fisher's theory & the Cambridge Cash balance approach provided a similar results of a direct relationship between quantity of money and nominal income.
Irving Fisher's equation of exchange:
MV = PT
V is velocity of money T is Volume of transactions
Cambridge approach:
M^d = KPY
K is the proportion of nominal income held as cash
-> While both resulted in similar conclusions & only focussed on money's role for transactions, they also had significant differences.
Differences between Fisher & Cambridge theories
1. Fisher focussed on velocity of money (V) whereas the Cambridge theory focussed on proportion of income held as cash (K) 2. Fisher focussed only supply of money and neglected money demand function, whereas Cambridge approach laid focus on both demand & supply functions. 3. Fisher approach focussed on the flow concept of money whereas Cambridge approach focussed on stock concept. 4. Fisher's approach highlighted the medium of exchange function of money whereas Cambridge approach focussed on store of value function. 5. The factors on which the theory depended is different as 'V' varies based on institutional factors whereas 'k' varies based on behavioural factors.
Cambridge approach is considered superior Fisher theory as it considers both demand and supply functions & used 'k' instead of 'V'. But in present context, both theories are not completely relevant as they neglect the speculatory demand for money & interest rate elasticity of money demand.
The later theories of liquidity preference of Keynes, Friedman's theory & Post-Keynesian theories provide greater insight in present context.