Topper Copies

Explain different version of equal sacrifice rule with the help of diagrams. Does equal sacrifice rule necessarily imply a progressive taxation?

S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025

Equal Sacrifice rule is a part of the Ability to pay theory of taxation which was supported by economists such as Pigou. -> It has 3 major versions: 1. Equal absolute sacrifice 2. Equal proportional sacrifice 3. Equal Marginal Sacrifice

[a diagram]

Equal Absolute Sacrifice

-> According to this principle, each taxpayer is made to sacrifice the same absolute amount such that the difference between utility from income before tax & utility from income after tax is same for all tax payers.

[a diagram]

U(Y) - U(Y-T)

[two graphs of marginal utility against income level, Rich Person: A on the left and Poor Person: B on the right, each with a downward-sloping marginal utility curve and a hatched area between P and Q (P' and Q' for B)]

-> When rich person tax PQ, loss in absolute utility is ar (PQRS) & for poor Person (P' ar (P'Q'R'S')

∴ Tax would be levied such that ar (PQRS) = ar (P'Q'R'S')

Equal Proportional Sacrifice.

-> Each taxpayer is made to pay the tax such that the proportional loss of utility or sacrifice made proportionally is same for all tax payers.

(U(Y) - U(Y-T)) / U(Y) is same.

Let say, if tax is levied at CD & C'D' levels, then,

ar(DQRC) / ar(OQRM) = ar(D'Q'R'C') / ar(O'Q'R'M')

Equal Marginal Sacrifice

-> Each payer is taxed such that the marginal utility from after the tax is same for all tax payers. d(U(y-T)) / dy is same for all.

[two graphs A and B of marginal utility against income, each with a downward-sloping curve MU and MU_B, with points G, I and income points O, H, Q (O', H', Q' for B)]

->If A is taxed HQ & B is taxed H'Q', the marginal utility after tax payment for both is the same GH = G'H'

-> This principle also results in the least aggregate sacrifice.

Equal sacrifice principle results in Progressive taxation as it is based on the principle of diminishing marginal utility of income. Thus higher taxation on reach leads to lower loss of utility than the poor & this results in rich paying more taxes than poor.