Is Friedman's quantity theory of money close to Classical or Keynesian approach to the aggregate demand for money? Given justifications for your arguments.
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
Milton Friedman accepted the Keynesian emphasis of money as an asset and restated the Classical quantity theory of money in light of Keynesian theory.
According to Friedman, demand for money demands on: 1. Nominal income (PY) 2. Interest rates of diverse assets - from equities (r_E) - from bonds (r_B) - from durable goods (r_D)
Thus demand for money is given as:
M^d = F(P, Y, r_E, r_B, r_D)
M^d = k(r_B, r_E, r_D) PY
where, k is the proportion of nominal income held as cash.
And this k depends on interest rate of assets.
Friedman & Classical theory of money demand
1) Similarities 1. The money demand function is similar to Cambridge approach with money demand having direct relation with nominal income. 2. Friedman stated that money demand function is stable and k is also stable - This results in convergence of Friedman's theory to classical theory 3. Classical assumptions of full employment, perfect competition were employed. 4. Friedman also emphasized on neutrality of money in long run.
2) Differences 1. He accepted the role of money as an asset 2. Quantity of money affects output & employment in short run in Friedman's theory. 3. By emphasizing the role of interest rates and impact of policies on real variables in short run, this differed from Classicals.
Friedman & Keynesian theories of money demand
1) Similarities 1. Emphasis of asset function of money. 2. Dependence of money demand interest rates. 3. Policy effectiveness on real variables in short run.
But there are significant differences.
2) Differences 1. Friedman emphasised that money demand and private sector stable - Whereas Keynes highlighted the instability in money demand function. 2. Keynes differentiated between transactionary & Speculative demand for money - No such difference in Monetarist model. 3. Keynes mentioned that money demand was highly elastic to interest rates causing liquidity trap - But Friedman's emphasised on very low elasticity of money demand to interest rates.
These points highlight that the Friedman's emphasis on stable M^d & R makes this theory closer to classical model with incorporation of few Keynesian elements.