How does portfolio balance approach differ from monetary approach in determining the exchange rate?
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
Monetary approach is an extension of domestic monetarism to external economy, which determines external balance by equating money supply and money demand.
Money demand, M^d = kPY
Money Supply, M^s = m(D+F)
where, D denotes domestic & F denotes foreign money supply.
Thus, any imbalance between money demand and supply needs to be balanced by exchange rate changes or capital inflows if domestic money supply remains unchanged. As per the Purchasing power parity theory, exchange rate (R) = P/P* where P is domestic price level & P* is foreign price level.
M^S/M^S* = kPY/kP*y* => P/P* = M^S P* y* / M^S* P Y
R = P/P* ∝ M^S/M^S*
According to monetary approach exchange rate is determined by changes in money supply and nominal income.
Portfolio balance Approach
This approach differs from monetary approach as it does not assume perfect substitutability of domestic and foreign assets.
Monetary approach showed perfect substitutability between assets and determined that
i - i* = EA => Uncovered interest parity
where i is domestic interest rates i* is foreign interest rates EA is expected appreciation of foreign currency.
Portfolio approach modified this by adding imperfect substitutability and introduced risk premium (RP) in the model. The exchange rate is determined by balancing portfolios across countries
i - i* = EA + RP.
Thus any changes in nominal income, wealth and interest rates would have an impact on exchange rates.