Topper Copies

Distinguish between internal Rate of Return (IRR)’ and ‘Net Present Value (NPV)’ criteria of evaluating public investment projects. What is the role of shadow prices in this context?

S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025

Internal Rate of Return (IRR) : Net Present Value (NPV) help in evaluating the viability of public investment projects in terms of monetary profitability and economic returns.

IRR is the rate which discounts equalizes the NPV with future cash flows from the project. NPV is the present value of the project which is calculated by discounting the future flows from the project with the rate of return.

NPV = C1/(1+r) + C2/(1+r)² + C3/(1+r)³ + ...

If the current market rate of borrowing which shows the cost of capital is less than the internal rate of return, then the public investment project is considered viable due to its positive returns

If the Net Present Value is greater than the replacement cost of firm's assets then the market values the project, thereby supporting investment.

But, these criteria consider market prices for cost-benefit analysis. In an underdeveloped economy, market prices may not truly reflect the real costs due to imperfect mechanism of markets. Also in cases of social costs of projects such as relocation of people for infrastructure projects, these market prices do not reflect these costs.

Role of Shadow prices in this context

Shadow prices reflect the true intrinsic prices which enables effective social cost-benefit analysis.

In cases of imperfect credit markets, there would be a shortage of credit at existing interest rates and this underestimates market rates and project cost. Shadow prices help in effective project planning by considering true market variables.

Shadow prices help in programme implementation. In underdeveloped and imperfect markets, inflation and labour markets imperfection limit true analysis of implementation of policies.

Shadow prices help in evaluating project costs and aid in effective planning, implementation and analysis of public investment.