“Explain the circumstances under which monetary and fiscal policy measures may be ineffective in stimulating economic growth or managing economic downturns. Discuss the potential limitations and challenges faced by policymakers in implementing these policies.
S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025
Monetary policy may remain in the case of poor monetary transmission where the first stage fails to operate. This occurs in the case of liquidity trap where rise in money supply fails to reduce interest rates. It can also remain in case of high cash to deposit ratio where people prefer to hold cash.
Fiscal policy may remain ineffective in stimulating economic growth when there are supply side bottlenecks with lack of excess capacity in the economy. In this case, fiscal policy results in inflation without change in output. Fiscal policy according to Keys IS-LM framework remains ineffective. When investment is perfectly elastic to interest rates. In this case any government spending leads to complete crowding out.
Limitation / challenges in implementing policies.
1. Monetary Policy - (i) Presence of informal and black economy. - (ii) Investment in unproductive assets and poor financial inclusion. - (iii) Adequate resources with bank and lack of pass through of policy rates. - (iv) Poor policy coordination limits controlling inflation. 2. Fiscal policy - (i) Fiscal burden and demand for fiscal consolidation with rising debts. - (ii) Supply bottlenecks like monsoon dependence in agriculture.
Successful implementation required inter policy coordination and outcome based policing.