Topper Copies

Analyse the efficacy of monetary and fiscal policy with high but not perfect capital mobility in the IS-LM-BP model under (i) Fixed exchange rate; (ii) Flexible exchange rate.

S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025

The IS-LM-BP model provides for understanding the impact of expenditure changing and switching policies on BoP equilibrium & Domestic equilibrium under constant prices assumption.

(i) Fixed exchange Rate (R)

When capital mobility is very high, the BP curve is more flatter than the LM curve due to high responsiveness of capital flows to interest rate changes. In the case of fixed exchange rates, BP curve does not shift as Interest or exchange rates remain constant.

[Figure 1: IS-LM-BP graph with an upward-sloping BP line, curves IS, IS', LM, LM', Y and Y^F on the income axis]

[Figure 2: IS-LM-BP graph with a horizontal BP line, curves IS, IS', LM, LM', Y and Y^F on the income axis]

Figure ① shows the case of high but not perfect capital mobility. In this case fiscal policy is used to achieve domestic equilibrium to reach full employment (Y_F) level of income. This shifts IS curve & this results in BoP surplus as greater capital flows are induced with small increase in interest rates. Thus tight monetary policy is used to achieve external equilibrium.

But in figure 2, which shows perfect capital mobility, only fiscal policy is effective as monetary policy decreases interest rates which lead to capital outflow and fall in money supply to limit over forex reserves.

(ii) Flexible exchange rates

In case of flexible exchang rates, BP curve shifts right with depriciation as lesser interest rates and capital inflows are required due to improvement in trade balance with depreciation.

[IS-LM-BP graph with IS, IS', BP, BP', LM, LM', LM'' and a point E]

In case of flexible rates, Monetary policy is more effective as an increase in money supply, with easy monetary policy shifts LM curve to LM' & this leads to BOP deficit at point E & causes depreciation.

Depreciation shifts IS & BP curves to the right and LM curve shifts left as it reduces real money supply. Thus new equilibrium is reached.

In this case fiscal policy is less effective as it leads greater interest rates and appreciation due to BOP surplus in the economy due to capital inflows. This shifts back IS curve & reduces the impact of fiscal policy.

Thus fiscal policy is more effective in case fixed R & monetary policy is more effective in case of flexible R.