Topper Copies

Critically analyse the role of Regional Trade Agreements in the creation and diversion of trade.

S Varshith Reddy, AIR 259, 2025

Regional trade agreements are regional trade grouping among countries to promote free trade among the nations while having a similar external tariff policy. - Ex: ASEAN group with free trade among the nations.

Trade creation from RTAs.

[a supply and demand graph of good x, price axis marked 1 and 2, with regions a, b, c, d]

Let say there are 3 nations as 1, 2 & 3 with nation 1 importing good X.

Nation 2 is low cost supplier and supplies at price ₹1 & Nation 3 supplies ₹1.5

Nation 1 impose non discriminatory 100% tariffs and imports from low cost nation at price Z2. If Nation 1 forms a RTA with nation 2 and eliminates its tariffs with nation 1 it leads to trade creation as it shifts production from inefficient producers in Nation 1 to low cost producers in Nation 2.

While the producer surplus falls by 'aa' & government revenue declines by 'c', consumer surplus increases by 'a+b+c+d' & resulting in net gain of b+d.

Thus trade creation increases global welfare & that of nation as due to allocative efficiency.

Trade Diversion from RTAs.

Trade diversion occurs when imports are replaced from low cost producing nation to a higher cost producing nation in the RTA grouping.

[a supply and demand graph of good x, price axis marked 2, 1.5 and 1, with regions a, b, c, d, e]

- If Nation 1 forms an RTA with Nation 3, then Price from Nation 3 becomes attractive.

Nation 1 will import from nation 3 at ₹1.5 and this shifts production from efficient nation 2 to high cost producers in Nation 3. Since the price reduced even in this case, it creates both trade creation & trade diversion.

The nation I will have a net welfare effect of 'b+d-e', as e is tariff loss which is not accompanied by low prices. Thus the more elastic Demand & Supply curves, the closer are the supply difference between 2 nations and less in quantity of component 'e'. This can still result in net welfare gain.

Regional trade agreements have other effects such as greater market expansion, economies of scale & investment and this has paved way for greater agreements in recent times.