Discuss classical view on monetary and fiscal policy. Why is monetary policy considered neutral and fiscal policy seen as ineffective in influencing real variables in the long-run?
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
under classical model , real variables like output, employment and real money supply are supply-determined due to prevalance of below assumptions -
1. Auction of labor market 2. markets clear 3. Says' law ( supply creates its own demand ) 4. Perfect Information
[three classical-model graphs: the production function Y = f(N, K̄) with Y = Yf and Nf; the AS-AD graph of price against output with a vertical AS at Y = Yf and AD(Ms); and the labour market with Ns and Nd determining Nf]
Fig: classical Model
Ns = f(w/P) (+ve) Nd = f(w/P) (-ve) → determines Nf
Y = f(N, K̄) Md = KPY Y = Yf
view on Monetary Policy
As per classical view, there is classical dichotomy due to Money neutrality Money is important as it determines the stability of prices but it does not the real variables. There is theoretical separation of real variables determined by supply side conditions like level of technology, capital stock
MONEY IS NEUTRAL
[a graph of price against output with a vertical AS at y = y_s and two AD curves, AD(M1) above AD(M0), at price levels P1 and P0, with a box M1>M0]
classical AD is implicit demand for money derived from cambridge real cash balance approach. Hence, M^d = K̄ P Ȳ AS Money Supply Increases, there will be direct and equiproportionate increase in prices due to "Too much money chasing too few goods". But output and employment won't change due to monetary expansion as change in prices wont impact real wages amidst wage price flexibility.
INEFFECTIVE FISCAL POLICY
This can be explained using classical theory of Interest (Theory of Loanable Funds) since interest rate acts as stabilising mechanism, there won't be impact on AD due to changes in investment demand or consumption demand or government expenditure.
[a loanable funds graph of interest rate against S, I and G: upward-sloping S, shifted I+(G-T) curves, interest rate rising from r0 to r1]
Fig: Theory of Interest rate
r0 → r1 Hence, consumption ↑ and investment falls. overall increase in government expenditure would be neutralised by fall in consumption and investment, hence AD(=C+I+G) would have no impact