Topper Copies

What is natural monopoly? Explain why a monopolist can’t be forced to charge a price equal to marginal cost?

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

Monopoly entails presence of single seller producing good with no close substitute and restricted entry and exit of firms.

Natural Monopoly exists when presence of single seller is due to cost conditions.

For example. 5 firms producing 20 units each would lead to price P1 higher than 1 firm producing price P2 (P1 >> P2)

Hence, Natural Monopoly

[a graph of cost against quantity with a falling AC curve, prices P1 and P2 marked on the cost axis, and quantities 20 and 100]

for example : Indian Railways

A monopolist uses profit maximising condition ie (MC = MR) to find prices and determine output based on price. Since demand curve of monopolist is negatively sloped and it earns supernormal profits, P > MR.

In given case, if P = MC (Marginal cost) then, MC > MR and monopolist would (∵ P>MR) face losses, finally quits the market.

[a graph of monopolist equilibrium: AR, MR and MC curves with P₀, P₁, Q₀ and Q₁ marked]

If P₁ = MC then monopolist would be producing Q₁ (based on AR). But at Q₁, MC > MR which would incur losses to monopolist. Hence, monopolist would set prices P₀ and quantity Q₀ to remain in market and P>MR