“Balanced budget is not fiscal neutral”. Comment.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Balanced Budget indicates when increase in government Expenditure is financed by equal and proportionate increase in taxes ie ΔG = ΔT
It leads to Balanced Budget Multiplier Theorem under Keynesian economics (BBM)
Balanced Budget Not fiscally neutral
Y = C + I + G = C̄ + c(Y – T) + I + G = C̄ + cY – cT + I + G Y = 1/(1–c) ( C̄ – cT + I + G)
Hence, ΔY/ΔG = 1/(1–c) where c is the marginal propensity to consume
ΔY/ΔT = –c/(1–c)
Adding both, ΔY/ΔG + ΔY/ΔT = 1/(1–c) – c/(1–c)
∵ ΔT = ΔG under Balanced budget
ΔY/ΔG = 1 ∴ ΔY = ΔG
Hence, under balanced budget there is equal and proportionate increase in output (equal to amount of government expenditure) because expansionary effect of government expenditure on output is more than the contractionary effect of taxation increase.
However, in case of open economy DY = DG would not hold true and BBM might not be equal to 1