Topper Copies

When is it more effective to pursue a Hirschmanian strategy compared to Nurksian balanced growth model approach? Discuss after explaining the essence of both the models.

Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025

Hirshman's unbalanced growth strategy calls for deliberate unbalancing of economy by investing in selected strategic sectors and thereby using external economies arising from it for development of other sectors According to Hirshman, developing countries do not have enough resources to invest in all sectors simultaneously. Thus, they should use that path of expansion which maximizes induced decision making. According to him, development can be in 2 ways :- (i) Excess of social overhead cost → DPA eg Development of infrastructure → more industries (ii) Shortage of SOC (SOC => DPA -> SOC) eg More industry -> demand better infrastructure

[a graph of DPA against SOC with a 45 degree line and stepped paths through A, A', B, B', B", C, C']

* According to traditional view, development via excess SOC (AA'BB"C) is more smooth.

However, according to Hirschman, development via shortage of SOC (AB'BC'C) compels more investment and thus is more efficient.

Balanced Growth

According to this, there should be systematic and strategic investment in all sectors so that we have harmonious development of all sectors of the economy. According to Nurske, low income countries are trapped by 'low income trap' from both demand and supply side.

Thus, to come out of it, there is a need to invest in all sectors so that each sector creates demand for other sectors as well & economy benefits from complementarities and external economies.

When Hirschman's strategy more effective ?

1. In case of developing countries who lack resources to go for balanced growth strategy. 2. For countries who are planning their growth strategy for short run, unbalanced growth could be a means to go for balanced growth in future. 3. where such 'strategic sectors' exist whose development is likely to benefit rest of the economy.

Thus, for developing country, Hirschman's Strategy could be a means to achieve balanced growth in long run, as emphasized by Nurske.