Topper Copies

Evaluate the impact of import quotas and tariffs on the allocation of resources within the economy. How do these trade policies influence the production and consumption of goods?

Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025

Import quotas and tariff imposition are forms of trade restrictions which countries use for their benefit. while quota is a form of quantity restriction imposed w.r.t. import or export, tariff is a form of tax on import or export. Assuming small country case, the impact of quota and tariff is same.

[a supply and demand graph with Sx, Dx, SF and SF+T, regions a, b, c, d and quantities Q1 to Q4; legend: Sx - Supply of X, Dx - demand of X, SF+T - Supply of X after tariff imposition of 100%]

* Intersection of Dx & Sx indicates autarky equilibrium point A. * when there is free trade, we have supply curve SF.

Now, suppose govt imposes tariff of 100% which shifts supply curve S_F by (T) to S_F+T.

Welfare effects - Loss of consumer surplus = -(a+b+c+d) - Gain in producer surplus = + a - Govt. Revenue from tariff = + C - Net loss of welfare = -(b+d)

And consumption is reduced by (Q4-Q3) production increases by (Q2-Q1) in domestic economy. Now, consider that govt. impose quota restriction of quantity JK We will have same result as we saw in case of tariff imposition. In fact, if we assume that govt. collects quota fees equal to area C in the diagram, we will have same welfare effect in case of both tariffs and quotas. However, it should be noted that in instances of change in demand conditions, impact of tariff & quota differs.

[a supply and demand graph with demand shifting from D1 to D2, with points J, K, J', K']

⊛ Here, if demand increases from D₁ to D₂ :- 1. Tariff - no change in prices, only quantities consumed increases. 2. Quota - It leads to increased prices with same amount of quantity (J'K' = JK) imported.

Here, in case of quota, we have more domestic production compared to tariff because of increased prices, but domestic Consumption is less. Thus, in general, tariff & quota increases domestic production, however, they also lead to reduced consumption because of higher domestic price.