Topper Copies

Under what 'macroeconomic conditions can expansionary fiscal policy lead to "Crowding in" rather than Crowding out? Explain

Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025

'Crowding out' is the fallin investment due to rise in government expenditure due to rise in interest rate as liquidity squeeze happens,

'crowding in' is just opposite, which is private sector's role increase due to rise in government expenditure.

This could happen when:-

1. Rise in government expenditure is coupled with subsidy for investment

[two graphs: an IS-LM graph with IS shifting to IS' so that interest rate rises from i₀ to i₁ and output from Y₀ to Y₁; and an investment demand graph with the investment line shifting right from I₀ to I₁]

Even if interest rate rise any fiscal expansion will also raise investment (shown: Panel II) as subsidy is given for investment eg PLI scheme post 2020, improved investment (Crowding in) despite enormous rise in government expenditure. 2. When Government expenditure is for creation of social overhead capital → 'Crowding in': ∴ investment in productive areas like roads/transport, formation of industrial corridors, digital infrastructure improvement → Crowding in, due to external economies and improvement in Ease of doing business.

Survey 2019-20 pointed out that post 1991 (LPG reforms), Public expenditure led to crowding in. 3. Situation of liquidity Trap where sentiments are bearish and pump-priming by government creates positive sentiments and lead to private investment.

[an IS-LM graph with a horizontal LM and IS shifting to IS', output rising from Y₀ to YF]

This happens when economy is at less than full employment output otherwise rise in prize will crowd out. 4. Promotion of saving habits by the government also create excess savings → reduce cost of Capital and leads to crowd in

therefore, government expenditure does not always lead to crowd-out. if policies are well co-ordinated and focused.

Programmes like Bharatmala, Nahoral infrastructure pipeline, leads to crowdin than crowdout.