Under what conditions does monetary policy become ineffective in IS-LM Framework?
Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025
'Monetary policy' concerned with money supply (M3) change and interest rate to achieve objective of inflation targeting or Growth.
Ineffectiveness of monetary policy first shown by Keynes via 'Liquidity trap', where individuals will hold all money and interest rate sensitivity of money demand is zero. This is because of future expectation of bond price fall and rise in interest rate.
[an IS-LM graph: a downward-sloping IS and an LM that is flat at a low interest rate and then rises steeply, noted "Lm=Lm''", with y₀ and yn marked]
Lm=Lm'' This makes Lm horizontal (perfectly elastic).
Any change in money supply (Dovish monetary policy) will not shift Lm' due to ∞ interest rate sensitivity of md and all rise in money supply will be absorbed in form of money eld for cash balance and 1st stage of transmission fails.
Also, when 'IS' is fully inelastic, meaning, Investment is interest rate insensitive as in (pure Keynes), then Monetary Policy will be fully ineffective as money supply rises due to monetary expansion, interest fall as 1st stage of transmission works fully, but since 'interest rate' has no role in investment demand, no rise in investment takes place, so 2nd stage of transmission fails.
[an IS-LM graph: a vertical IS at y₀ with LM₀ shifting down to LM₁, the interest rate falling and output unchanged; side note: only interest rate will fall due to excess supply of money at original interest rate, there will be no change in output]
Therefore fully elastic 'LM' or fully inelastic IS will lead to ineffective Monetary Transmission.