Topper Copies

"If firms produce differentiated products it is neither possible to identify the industry nor possible to draw its supply curve."Discuss and show how Chamberlin handles the problem.

Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025

In monopolistic competition where firms produce differentiated products, the problem of non-existence of industry supply curve, solved by E.H. chamberlin via heroic assumption of symmetry and uniformity.

By symmetry, he meant that preferences of individuals are a symmetrically distributed, and any single firm does not have any control over the market.

Any change in price by the firm will not affect large market and will have negligible effect as other's will not follow.

This leads to perceived demand curve or planned sales curve.

On the other hand, assumption of uniformity meant, preferences are 'uniformly spaced', Any change in price will also attract reaction by other firms.

This lead to proportional demand curve.

The intersection of proportional & planned sales curve will lead to final equilibrium.

[a graph of P against output with a straight downward line labelled Proportional and a curved line labelled Perceived intersecting at a point, with dotted lines to P and q]

Therefore, chamberlin's heroic assumption solved the problem of supply curve by 'grouping' industry.