Topper Copies

Discuss classical view on monetary and fiscal policy. Why is monetary policy considered neutral and fiscal policy seen as ineffective in influencing real variables in the long-run?

Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025

Classicals were supply side economists where market clears and perfect wage-price flexibility maintains.

Monetary policy is considered neutral due to assumption of "classical dichotomy", which says that nominal variables like money supply change will not affect real factors like output, real interest rate and employment.

this they explained via Classical AD, which is derived from Fisher's quantity theory of money (QTm) i.e. MV = PY, by considering 'V' constant, any rise or fall in money supply (m) will lead to rise or fall in price and as perfect wage-price flexibility is assumed, workers will adjust their supply:

[two graphs: price against output with AD₀ shifting up and a vertical AS at Y₀; and a labour market with an upward-sloping supply and downward-sloping demand meeting at L₀]

if money supply rises AD₀ will shift up to AD₁ and AS is perfectly inelastic, full and complete effect will be there in price and in figure 2, no change in labour market will be there.

Therefore, monetary policy is neutral

Fiscal policy is ineffective as this will affect real interest rate in 'loanable fund market' but any expansionary or Contractionary fiscal policy will be fully absorbed via rise or fall in interest rate and no change in 'investment' will takeplace, which will not shift 'AS' curve.

[a loanable fund market graph: upward-sloping supply LS, demand curves dd₀ and dd₁ shifting right, interest rates i₀ and i₁]

Any rise in Government expenditure for example will shift demand for loanable fund from dd₀ to dd₁ .

This will raise interest rate due to excess demand, which will (crowdout) private investment due to rise in cost of capital and supply of funds will rise to higher opportunity cost of holding money.

The entire rise in government expenditure will be fully absorbed.

But if fiscal policy has supply side effect (like reduction in tax rate) this could lead to rise in labour supply and shift AS further to raise output.

Therefore, money is neutral because it has no real effect , and fiscal policy is ineffective as it change interest rate, but not output.