Topper Copies

Does a monopolistically competitive market lead to excess capacity under price competition?

Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025

A monopolistically competitive market is the one which produce differentiated get similiar products, which are not homogeneous by large number of firms.

E.H. chamberlin in his "theory of monopolistic competition" maintains that in 'prize Competition' where both perceived demand curve and proportional demand curve intersect each other at equilibrium output [does not] lead to 'Excess capacity' rather it is [social cost] of producing differentiated Products.

As price Competition prevails, perceived demand Curve function due to Symmetricity principle', each firm believe that competitor will not change price in response to his change in price.

[a graph of AR prop. and AR perceived lines with a U-shaped LAC, equilibrium points e, e' and e'', and quantities q'm, qm and qc marked; arrows below the axis mark "Excess capacity" between q'm and qm and "Scope/Benefit for Diversity" between qm and qc]

if there is price Competition the equilibrium exists at 'e'' at quantity q'm' which is though less than qc but chamberlin did not termed it as excess capacity.

However, if non-price competition prevails, then perceived d/d curve (AR) will become redundant, and firm will compete on quantity basis by entry' this will shift AR prop. (CD) to c'd' leftwards, and equilibrium will be attained at e'' and quantity qm'', which is less than chamberlin's optimum output.

Therefore, in Price Competition excess capacity does not prevails.

But Robinson terms [qm' qc] as excess capacity an in that sense also

downward sloping AR -> Excess Capacity

not Price-Band Competition