Discuss the Stackelberg model of oligopoly. How does it differ from Cournot model in terms of assumptions about firm behavior? What is the significance of the first-mover advantage in this model?
Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025
Stackleberg model (Top-dog model) a duopoly model involving 'follower' and a 'leader' based on mutual recognition of each others interdependence in a quantity based competition.
Both observe each other therefore, Conjectural variation is non-zero.
In this model leader by virtue of first entered into the market will produce more output than follower. and non-collusive type of duopoly will exist.
Suppose, P = a-bq
where
q = q1+q2
and marginal cost Both firms is zero,
Leader will include the reaction his profit function of 'firm 2' in his profit function.
So for follower's reaction function -
F.O.C., ∂π₂/∂q₂ = 0
for π₂ = (TR)₂ - (TC)₂
π₂ = (a - b(q₁+q₂)) q₂ - ①
dπ₂/dq₂ = a - bq₁ - 2bq₂ = 0
q₂ = (a - bq₁)/2b - ①
putting equation ① (the reaction function of firm 2') in to Profit function of firm 1 -
π₁ = (TR)₁ - (TC)₁
π₁ = (a - b(q₁+q₂)) q₁ - ②
π₁ = (a - b(q₁ + (a-bq₁)/2b)) q₁ = 0
dπ₁/dq₁ = a - 2bq₁ - a/2 + bq₁ = 0
q1 = (a/2)/2b = a/4b
and q2 = (a - bq1)/2b = (a - (a/4b)b)/2b = a/4b
Leader's output (q1) = a/2b , Follower's output (q2) = a/4b
Carnot's model v/s Stackelberg's
| Carnot's model | Stackelberg's | |---|---| | 1) No learning by doing => C.V=0 | learn from each other's behaviour C.V. ≠ 0 | | II) Both produce same output | follower's output is less than leader's as shown above | | III) Total output is less than both Perfect Competition and Stackelberg's | Total output will be more than Cournot's, but less than perfect competition |
Significance of First mover'
1. more production to the leader, the first mover, the Top dog. [q_L = a/2b] and follower is producing half of his output. 2. Promote companies / nations R&D to gain first mover's advantage. eg Boeing's first move led to difficulty in establishment for AirBus. 3. Shows difference in standard of living and output growth rate in developing and underdeveloped.
therefore Stackleberg's model though assuming various assumption is an significant improvement over 'Cournot's' (1838) no-learning by doing Model and perfectly explains behaviour in 'quantity based' duopoly.