What is natural monopoly? Explain why a monopolist can’t be forced to charge a price equal to marginal cost?
Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025
Natural monopoly is the situation when fixed cost of Business is very high and economies of scale exists for long range of output. eg Powergrid, Coal mining (CIL) etc.
This disincentivise the potential competition to enter into the already captured market. Therefore role of government becomes important to raise social welfare.
[a graph with mc, AC and AR curves, price levels P, A, B and Pm, and outputs qm, qc and qe, points d, e, c, F marked]
if a natural monopolist like (CIL) Function as monopolist, it will change Price Pm and Qm 'quantity, but anti monopoly laws and goal of social Social welfare will not let him/her do it.
if government follows marginal Cost pricing [P = OB], quantity Qc this will lead to loss of monopolists as Area AECB, which will force her to go out of Business due to diminishing 'MC' and AC.
In this case, therefore Average cost pricing is followed as Price = OP and quantity Q_c' (Q_c' < Q_c).
This will certainly lead to dead weight loss, (Area dCf) but given the cost structure, this is 'most feasible' and keep the natural monopolist in market
'Competition' could be Promoted if government decides to handhold new comers at initial stage (eg AirBus) v/s Boeing to reap 'external economies' for longer period