“Balanced budget is not fiscal neutral”. Comment.
Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025
'Balanced Budget' means the receipts of the government due to additional taxation is equal. [ΔG = ΔT]
But this will not be fiscal-neutral as multiplier in this case would be '1' in case of lumpsum tax.
∵ As government increase spending by raising equivalent taxes the change in income would be equal to the spending. therefore:
[Δy = qg·ΔG] as qg = 1
[Δy = ΔG]
this is because →
in simple Keynesian framework →
Change in government expenditure will lead to [Δy = 1/(1-c) ΔG] change in output
but similar rise in lump sum tax, will reduce the value of multiplier by (-)cT/(1-c) amount.
which : while adding up make the multipliers = 1
ΔY/ΔG + ΔY/ΔT = 1/1-c + -c/1-c
[ΔY (1/ΔG + 1/ΔT) = 1]
Therefore, Balance Budget is not neutral in Keynes model, but in case of 'Classicals' fiscal policy & therefore Budget is fully ineffective