6. (a) What is a Customs' Union? Discuss the effects of a Customs' Union formation under partial equilibrium conditions.
Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025
Customs union is a form of economic integration among countries characterized by :- (i) free trade among member countries (ii) Common tariff policy for non- members. Eg European Union
The effect of Customs union depends on whether they are trade creating or trade diverting. A trade creating customs union leads to replacement of inefficient and high cost domestic production by cheaper & efficiently produced imports from member nation. On the other hand, when imports from an efficient producer nation which is a non - member are replaced by inefficient producer's import by a member country, it leads to trade diversion.
Suppose there are 3 countries:- 1, 2 & 3. For country 2, country 1 exports at $1 & country 3 at $1.5. Also, country 2 imposes 100% uniform tariff.
Now, if country 1 becomes a member of customs union, it is a trade creating customs union.
[supply-demand graph of price against quantity: Dx and Sx meeting at A, with horizontal lines S$+T and S$, areas a, b, c, d marked between them]
* Since country 1 is now member of customs union -> tariffs removed.
Welfare effect of trade creating customs union
- Gain in consumer surplus : +(a+b+c+d) - Loss in producer surplus : -a - Loss of tariff revenue : -c - Net welfare gain : b+d
Trade diverting customs union -> country 3 is member of customs union
[ovals for N1 ($1), N2 and N3 ($1.5) with an arrow to "Trade diversion", and a supply-demand graph with S1+T, S3 and S1 lines and areas a, b, c, d, e]
we compare Situation S3 with S1+T
Welfare analysis - Gain in consumer surplus : +(a+b+c+d) - Loss of producer surplus : - a - Loss of tariff revenue = - (c+e) - Net Gain/loss (b+d) - e
Net effect will depend on :- (i) higher elasticity of Sx & Dx -> higher chances of welfare gain (ii) lesser the distance between S1 & S1' -> higher chances of welfare gain
Thus countries having higher pre-union tariffs with members, and lower tariffs for non-members should form customs union to maximize welfare gains.