Both the marginal utility approach and the indifference curve approach yield the same equilibrium position for a rational consumer. Discuss the relative advantages of the indifference curve approach over the marginal utility approach.
Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025
while the marginal utility approach by Marshall used cardinal measurement, the indifference curve approach by Hicks and Allen emphasized on ordinal utility measurement.
Similarities in both approaches 1. Both assume rational consumers who want to maximize their satisfaction. 2. Similar equilibrium conditions :-
| MU Approach | IC Approach | |---|---| | MUx/Px = MUy/Py = MUm | MRSxy = Px/Py | | | MUx/MUy = Px/Py | | | MUx/Px = MUy/Py |
3. Both assume diminishing utility :- - Marshall - Law of diminishing MU - I C Approach - MRS is declining 4. Introspective method - Individuals own evaluation w.r.t. MU & MRS
However, IC approach has the following advantages :- 1. Since it does not rely on ordinal measurement of utilities , it is more realistic 2. MUm is not assumed to be constant 3. Admits existence of income effect while MU approach only talked about substitution effect 4. Explains the existence of giffen good using income & substitution effect 5. Abandoned hypothesis of independent utilities and thus IC approach admits existence of substitute & complementary goods.
But despite these limit benefits, IC approach has following disadvantages:- 1. Cannot analyze behaviour under uncertainty. 2. Transitivity may not be found in real life (Alexander) 3. Cardinal measurement is implicit
Thus, IC approach was an improvement over MU approach and explained price effect as a combination of income & substitution effect.