Topper Copies

Distinguish between Ricardo and Kalecki theories of distribution.

Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025

Ricardo's theory explains distribution of national income among various factors of production while Kalecki relied on Lerner's measure of monopoly to establish relation between share of profit in national income and degree of monopoly.

Differences 1. Ricardo assumed diminishing returns but Kalecki did not 2. According to Ricardo, profit is a necessary incentive for capital formation. Kalecki did not assume this. 3. Ricardo relied on Malthusian theory of population while Kalecki did not 4. Ricardo assumed existence of subsistence wage while Kalecki did not assume this. 5. Ricardo assumed capital mobility between agriculture and industry to explain his theory. Kalecki explained it using only capitalist i.e. profit earners & workers i.e. wage earners 6. Ricardian theory emphasized on existence of 'rent', measured by (AP_L - MP_L). Kalecki only had profit & wage share in national income. 7. In Ricardian theory, with capital formation, share of wages, both absolute & relative increases and that of profit reduces. In Kalecki's theory, as degree of monopoly increase, share of profit in national income increase and that of wages fell. 8. Ricardo explained 'Stationary state' - a gloomy state where no capital formation, no profits & no growth occurs. Kalecki did not touch upon it. 9. Empirically, Ricardo's theory of increasing wage share failed while Kalecki was able to explain constancy of wages because of cheaper raw materials from colonies. 10. Kalecki assumed short run AC=MC. Ricardo did not assume this.

Therefore, though Ricardo's theory has some positives like explaining the existence of rent, empirically, Kalecki's theory is more relevant when it comes to explaining constantancy of wages.