How does Amartya Sen's capability approach provide an alternative perspective on welfare criteria? Discuss its key principles and implications for welfare analysis.
Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025
Amartya Sen's Capability approach emphasizes on impact of policies on capabilities of individuals to decide whether or not they increase social welfare. Amartya Sen defined capability as an asset indigenous to individuals which enables them to participate in society in a healthy way. Capabilities ensure :- 1. Individuals are able to make use of existing opportunities 2. Individuals participate in governance.
Capability Approach as an alternative Amartya Sen transformed welfare analysis which was earlier focused on UTILITARIANISM, by shifting focus towards CAPABILITARIANISM. Utilitarianism emphasized on maximizing utilities of individuals to maximize social welfare. However, Amartya Sen criticised it on following points :- 1. Utility need not necessarily imply well-being. 2. Measuring utilities is a flawed concept.
Amartya Sen also criticised existing welfare criterias like Pareto optimality because :- 1. we can achieve pareto optimality with poors living in misery and rich rolling in luxuries 2. A redistribution which increases leisure and income of individuals need not necessarily imply improvement in well-being if it leads to loss of freedoms and abandonement of cherished traditions.
According to Sen, enabling factors like education, health, skilling, conducive political environment, etc. are several factors which increase capabilities by increasing freedoms which people have.
To conclude, an increase in income of a family need not necessarily imply increase in social welfare according to Sen, if women of the family do not enjoy rights to spend that money.