Topper Copies

Discuss the potential impact of externalities on the assessment of welfare criteria. How do positive and negative externalities affect the efficiency and overall welfare?

Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025

Externalities are impacts of an activity on third party, who are not directly or indirectly involved in the transactions. Eg. Pollution caused by a firm affecting neighbouring population.

The welfare criterias like Pareto-Optimality are constructed on the assumption that there do not exist any externalities.

when externalities exist, as it happens in real world, Pareto optimality criteria fails to provide an efficient solution.

Positive externality and welfare A positive externality means that social returns from an activity are higher than private returns from it. Eg Education creates a civilized society which benefits members of society.

[a graph of SMB, PMB and MC against quantity, with points M and N and equilibria E0 and E1, the gap between PMB and SMB marked positive externality]

- MC - marginal cost - PMB - private marginal benefit - SMB - Social marginal benefit

Thus, existence of positive externality leads to underproduction of a good and thus yield inefficient outcome. MN indicates the amount by which the commodity i.e. education is falling short of its optimum level. Thus, overall welfare is less than what it could be had externalities been internalized.

Negative externality & welfare In case of negative externality, social cost of an activity exceeds private cost, leading to overproduction. Eg> Pollution

[a graph of MB against SMC (social MC) and PMC (private MC), with equilibria E0 and E1 and points M and N]

Thus, we have inefficient outcome at E1 and commodity is over-produced by amount MN. ↓↓ welfare is negatively affected Thus, if externalities are not internalized say by using pigovian taxes, coase theorem (permits), etc., it reduces overall welfare.