What are the similarities and difference between the Fisherian and Cambridge version of the Quantity Theory of Money?
Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025
Quantity theory of money is a hypothesis which states that changes in money supply leads to changes in prices.
Fisher's version has been termed as transaction approach to quantity theory of money. It is given by :-
MV_T = P_T T where M- money supply V_T- Velocity of money P_T- Price level T- Transactions
Alternatively, it can be written as :-
MV = PY
The Cambridge version of QTM was given by Marshall and Pigou as :-
m_s = M_d = K PY ↓ proportion of money nominal income held as money.
Similarities in both approaches 1. Both explains neutrality of money i.e. money only affect nominal variables like price level & no impact on real variables. 2. while Fisher assumed constant velocity of money since it is decided by institutional factors like length of pay period, etc.; in Cambridge version k was taken as constant (V=1/k). 3. Both assumed real output to be fixed at full employment level of output.
Differences 1. While Fisher emphasized money supply, Cambridge version emphasized on money demand. 2. Fisher included only medium of exchange function of money but Cambridge version included store of value function. 3. while Fisher used velocity in his version, Cambridge version used 'K' - a constant proportion of nominal income demanded as money.. 4. While Fisher equation emphasized that money affect price level, Cambridge version explained the economics behind it. As money supply increases, to hold ideal proportion of money, individuals spend the excess money on assets and goods ("Too much money chasing too few goods" leads to price rise.
Later on, Milton Friedman, in his paper "The Counter Revolution in Monetary Theory" reformulated QTM as a portfolio theory of money demand.