5. (c) Distinguish between 'Internal Rate of Return (IRR)' and 'Net Present Value (NPV)' criteria of evaluating public investment projects. What is the role of shadow prices in this context?
Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025
Net present value criteria of project evaluation
Net present value criteria of project evaluation involves evaluation of project by calculating present value of benefits, and deducting from it the present value of operation and maintainance cost and initial outlays.
NPV = -C₀ + (B₁-C₁)/(1+r) + (B₂-C₂)/(1+r)² + - - -
The criteria for chosing project is that its NPV should be positive and when two mutually exclusive projects are under consideration, that project should be choosen which has higher NPV.
Another criteria of project evaluation is IRR. It is the rate of discount at which NPV is zero. It shows the percentage rate of return which is implicit in cost & benefit flow. In case of mutually exclusive projects, that project should be choosen which has the highest IRR.
Role of Shadow prices
Shadow prices are used when we do not know the exact market price. These are generally used to account for externalities. Thus, by using shadow prices we can factor in things like pollution which is a negative externality or any positive externality like landscape improvement by the project could be included as benefit. Thus, shadow prices make our cost- benefit analysis is more comprehensive