4. (b) It is sometimes observed that a country's current account worsens immediately after a real currency depreciation and begins to improve only sometimes later. This phenomenon is popularly represented by J-curve. Explain the phenomenon.
Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025
In general, a real currency depreciation is expected to improve current account. However, in short run, it can worsen also. This is explained by J- curve analysis.
The impact of exchange rate change on current account balance is captured by Marshall - Lerner conditions :- Ex - elasticity of foreign demand for exports Em - Elasticity of domestic demand for imports
1. Ex + Em > 1 → trade balance improve from depreciation 2. Ex + Em < 1 → trade balance worsens from depreciation 3. Ex + Em = 1 → trade balance remain unchanged
[J curve graph of trade balance (X-m) against time: the curve dips below zero (trade deficit), then rises above zero to a plateau (trade surplus)]
In short run, as currency depreciates foreign price of our exports reduces while domestic price of our imports increases. However, there is a tendency of value of imports (Qm X Pm) to change faster than value of exports (Qx X Px). In other words, price effect dominates quantity effect in short run Thus while the price of import increases, its quantity remain more or less unchanged. But, though export price reduces, its quantity is not immediately increased. Thus, in short run, Ex + Em < 1 ↓ Depreciation -> worsened current account balance.
However, in long run, quantity effect shows up and export quantity respond to export prices (Similar thing for imports). Thus, in long run, depreciation leads to trade surplus.