4. (a) Under the Fixed Exchange Rate Regime, Central bank attempts to maintain fixed exchange rate. Why does central bank fail to do so. If the currency devaluation becomes inevitable, how does it lead to 'balance of payment crisis'? Can the timing of balance of payment crisis be predictable? Explain with diagram.
Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025
A central Bank fails to maintain exchange rate at its fixed level in case of speculative attack. A speculative attack means massive selling of domestic currency when it is believed to be overvalued, in expectations of gaining from it. Eg Black Wednesday (1992) -> massive selling of Euro -> depreciation. In case of speculative attack, devaluation becomes inevitable, and it might lead to loss of huge forex reserves if the currency is not devalued. Thus, devaluation has to be done in such cases.
Model
Assumptions 1. Perfect foresight of market participants 2. Central bank allows domestic credit expansion 3. Exchange rate is fixed at E₀
[graph of exchange rate against time with a rising shadow floating rate line E^S, dashed levels E^S_T'', E^S_T = E₀ and E^S_T' at times T'', T, T', and below the axis a forex reserve curve falling to zero at T marked "loss of forex reserve"]
Shadow floating exchange rate is the exchange rate if it is allowed to float freely. As domestic credit expands, inflation leads to depreciation as shown in upper panel. In the lower panel, forex reserves gradually decline and finally hit zero. ⇓ This is SPECULATIVE ATTACK
Timing of the attack
- why not at T'' If reserves were to hit zero at T'', people know that exchange rate would appreciate from E₀ to ES_T'. ⇓ Thus, they won't join speculative attack - why not at T' ? If reserves were to hit zero at T', people know that currency will depreciate at T'. Thus they start buying forex in exchange for domestic currency and thus reserves fall to zero even before i.e. at time T.
Thus, speculative attack can lead to failure of central bank to maintain exchange rate at fixed level.